Foul Witch
The Roberta's team's other room, the one for adults.
15 Avenue A, New York, NY 10009 · open Thursday through Monday · 5pm to 10pm
Sign in or create a free account to see pricing and book this table. Joining is free — you only pay when we land your reservation.
It is not a Resy problem. It is a 28-day window.
Foul Witch is the Italian room from Carlo Mirarchi and Brandon Hoy, the Roberta's owners, opened in 2023 to a wave of two-month waits that have not let up. The menu is pasta-led with a wood-fire grill at the back, the dining room sits about thirty, and a chef's counter holds another four.
Resy is the front door and the front door is jammed within the first minute of release. What Resy does not show is that the chef's counter takes its own bookings and that the bar accepts walk-ins for the full menu most weeknights.
How we work this room.
Pay when we get you in.
Your card is authorized when you submit the request. We charge it only when we confirm your table. No confirmation, no charge. Ever.
Authorize, do not captureThe host is expecting you.
You walk in to Foul Witch and the table is yours, held for your party at your time.
Confirmed for your partyOne posted price.
One number, every night, every party size. No auctions, no surge, no Friday markup. Whatever the room is doing, the price does not move. Sign in to see it.
No auctions. No surge.Foul Witch, the FAQ.
How do I get a reservation at Foul Witch?
Name Foul Witch and the night you want. We book it on your account the instant a table opens or a cancellation appears, and you only pay if we actually get it.
Why is Foul Witch so hard to book?
Foul Witch is one of the most in-demand tables in East Village. Prime-time seats are claimed within seconds of release, and many never reach the public at all, so refreshing on your own rarely works.
When do Foul Witch reservations open up?
Foul Witch releases tables on a set schedule, and seats also reappear when other guests cancel. We watch both around the clock and move the instant one opens, so you never have to refresh at midnight.
How much does it cost to book Foul Witch through The Elusive List?
One flat fee, charged only when we confirm your table. No table, no charge. Sign in to see the exact fee for Foul Witch.
Five steps, start to seated.
You ask.
Tell us the night, the time window, the party size. Two minutes on this page. Card on file, not charged.
We confirm the request.
An operator reviews the request, checks the room, and sends a confirmation that we are working it. Usually within thirty minutes.
We work the room.
We reach the floor manager directly, by phone or by text, depending on the night. We make the call.
You are confirmed.
We charge the card and send your confirmation — the time and the name to give the host.
You eat.
Walk into 15 Avenue A, give your name at the host stand, sit down. The room takes it from there. We do not see you again until the next request.
Italian, New York, Tier II.
Bad Roman
Comedy Cellar
Dhamaka
Tonight, tomorrow,
or three months out.
We work this restaurant every day. You pay only when we confirm your table.